Forum Message

Topic: Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model
Posted by: M. Edward (Ed) Borasky
Date/Time: 29/11/2002 06:07:57

I guess I don't see what "automata theory" as such has to do with NLP, New Code or otherwise. As an *applied* mathematician, I was very excited by automata theory, formal logic, theorem proving by machine, formal semantics of programming languages and other related disciplines, back about the time John and Richard were inventing / discovering NLP.

But all of the dreams I had of *practical applications* of these studies fell by the wayside. I now view them as a dry hole, although I'm sure my friends in cryptography have uses for them. :)

I find the models of John Holland's Complex Adaptive Systems much more inspiring, for example, as I do the practical techniques of artificial intelligence, artificial life, genetic programming, fuzzy logic, simulated annealing, etc. IMHO, NLP is about what works -- these tools work.

Once you get the basics of automata theory down, it's pretty much a bunch of theorems about what doesn't work. It's impossible to solve the halting problem, this or that problem is either unsolvable or requires exponential time to solve, you can't write an optimizing compiler for more than three registers, etc. I like having a bag of tools that give me usable solutions to real-world problems, not a bunch of theorems about what I can't do.


Entire Thread

TopicDate PostedPosted By
Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model28/11/2002 20:19:25John
     Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model28/11/2002 21:49:16SMH
          Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model29/11/2002 18:54:37John
               Re:Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model30/11/2002 06:14:39Stephen Hawley
     Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model29/11/2002 02:34:56John Grinder and Carmen Bostic St. Clair
          Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model29/11/2002 06:07:57M. Edward (Ed) Borasky
          Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model29/11/2002 19:06:00John
          Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model04/01/2003 06:50:38nj
               Re:Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model04/01/2003 09:21:05John
                    Re:Re:Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model04/01/2003 09:44:46nj
                         Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model04/01/2003 09:56:01John
                              Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model04/01/2003 10:06:40nj
               Re:Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model04/01/2003 10:00:21Patrick E.C. Merlevede, MSc. (jobEQ.com)
                    Re:Re:Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model04/01/2003 10:14:32nj
                         Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model04/01/2003 10:57:12Patrick E.C. Merlevede, MSc. (jobEQ.com)
                              Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model05/01/2003 19:07:07John Grinder
                                   Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model05/01/2003 19:59:12Patrick E.C. Merlevede, MSc. (jobEQ.com)
               Re:Epistemology & Chomsky Online Ref08/02/2004 13:11:32Sheamus
          Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model08/02/2004 07:13:55nj
               Re:Re:Re:Epistemology: questions regarding the discrete model08/02/2004 07:49:05nj

Forum Home